Wed. Jun 19th, 2024

Is it allowed to say “ _Assalam ala Manittaba al huda_ ” to a nonmuslim?Answered by…

By almaas Oct 30, 2020

Is it allowed to say “ _Assalam ala Manittaba al huda_ ” to a nonmuslim?

Answered by Shaykh Ibn al Uthaymeen:

“It’s not allowed for a human to give salam to a Muslim with the term, ” _Assalam ala Manittaba al huda_ “ because this phrase was uttered by the Rasul ﷺ when he wrote to nonmuslims. And your brother is a Muslim so say to him,”Assalamu alaykum”. And if you say, “Assalam ala Manittaba al Huda” it necessitates that your brother doesn’t follow the guidance (i.e Islam).

And if there are Muslims and Christians and one wants to send salam on them its customary to say,“Assalamu alaykum” and those who are addressed by it are Muslims only.“


لا يجوز أن يسلم الإنسان على المسلم بقوله : “السلام على من اتبع الهدى” ، لأن هذه الصيغة إنما قالها الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم حين كتب إلى غير المسلمين ، وأخوك المسلم قل له : “السلام عليكم” . أما أن تقول : “السلام على من اتبع الهدى” فمقتضى هذا أن أخاك هذا ليس ممن اتبع الهدى ، وإذا كانوا مسلمين ونصارى فإنه يسلم عليهم بالسلام المعتاد يقول : السلام عليكم، يقصد بذلك المسلمين.

By almaas

Related Post

Discover more from Hadith Library

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading